Get a free 30 minute consultation or fixed fee appointment. Begin Now

Insights & Guidance

Parental Alienation and Child Arrangements | Harrington Family Law

Parental Alienation: What Is It and How Can It Affect Child Arrangements?

When parents separate, emotions can run high, particularly when children are involved. Whilst most parents want what is best for their children, disagreements and unresolved conflict can sometimes result in children becoming caught in the middle.

In some circumstances, one parent may behave in a way that damages a child's relationship with the other parent. This is often referred to as parental alienation, although the Family Court increasingly focuses on the specific behaviours involved rather than the label itself.

At Harrington Family Law, we understand how upsetting and frustrating it can be when your relationship with your child is affected following separation. We also recognise the importance of understanding why a child may be reluctant to spend time with a parent before reaching conclusions.

What Is Parental Alienation?

Parental alienation is a term commonly used to describe circumstances where a child becomes resistant or hostile towards one parent, allegedly as a result of the influence or behaviour of the other parent.

However, the Family Court generally focuses on behaviours, rather than treating "parental alienation" as a medical diagnosis or automatically accepting that a child's reluctance to see a parent has been caused by manipulation.

Alienating behaviours may arise where a parent deliberately or unintentionally acts in a way that undermines a child's relationship with the other parent.

It is important to remember that a child refusing to spend time with a parent does not automatically mean that alienating behaviours have occurred. There may be other explanations, including the child's own experiences, parental conflict, domestic abuse or safeguarding concerns.

What Are the Signs of Alienating Behaviours?

Every family situation is different, but examples of behaviours that may cause concern include:

  • Speaking negatively about the other parent: Regularly criticising, insulting or undermining the other parent in front of the child.
  • Interfering with communication: Unreasonably preventing or discouraging telephone calls, messages or other forms of communication.
  • Making a child feel guilty: Suggesting that spending time with the other parent would upset or hurt the parent they live with.
  • Encouraging rejection: Pressuring a child to take sides or reject the other parent without a justified reason.
  • Sharing adult disputes: Involving children in arguments about finances, court proceedings or other matters that should remain between the adults.
  • Undermining child arrangements: Repeatedly interfering with agreed arrangements without a reasonable explanation.

These behaviours do not automatically establish that alienating behaviours have occurred. The circumstances, evidence and impact on the child must all be considered.

What If My Child Refuses to See Me?

One of the most difficult situations a parent can experience is when their child suddenly becomes reluctant or refuses to spend time with them.

This can be particularly distressing where there was previously a close and loving relationship.

However, it is important not to assume that the other parent is responsible for the child's reluctance.

Children may resist spending time with a parent for a variety of reasons, including anxiety surrounding separation, exposure to parental conflict, their own experiences with that parent or concerns about their safety.

The reasons behind a child's reluctance must be carefully explored to ensure that any decisions are made in their best interests.

How Does the Family Court Deal With Parental Alienation?

The Family Court's primary consideration when determining child arrangements is the welfare of the child.

Where allegations of alienating behaviours are raised, the Court will consider the evidence and whether those behaviours have affected the child's relationship with a parent.

Depending on the circumstances, the Court may:

  • Request a report from CAFCASS to consider the child's wishes, feelings and welfare.
  • Consider whether a fact-finding hearing is necessary to determine disputed allegations.
  • Make directions for further evidence or professional assessments where appropriate.
  • Consider arrangements that support the child's relationship with both parents, provided this is safe and in their best interests.
  • Make or vary a Child Arrangements Order.

The Court will also consider any allegations of domestic abuse or other safeguarding concerns. It is essential that genuine concerns about a child's safety are not incorrectly characterised as alienating behaviours.

There is no automatic presumption that a child must spend time with a parent where doing so would expose them to harm.

What Does CAFCASS Say About Alienating Behaviours?

CAFCASS recognises that children may become reluctant, resistant or refuse to spend time with a parent for a number of different reasons.

Its approach focuses on understanding the child's experiences and identifying the reasons behind their behaviour.

This is particularly important because a child's rejection of a parent does not, by itself, demonstrate that the other parent has manipulated them.

CAFCASS may consider the child's relationship with each parent, their experiences of family life, any safeguarding concerns and the impact of parental conflict.

The aim is to understand what is happening within the family and identify arrangements that best protect the child's welfare.

What Can I Do If I Am Concerned About Alienating Behaviours?

If you are concerned that your child's relationship with you is being deliberately undermined, it is important to approach the situation carefully.

Where safe and appropriate, you should try to maintain positive communication with the other parent and avoid involving your child in disagreements.

It may also be helpful to keep a clear record of missed arrangements, concerning communications and any significant changes in your child's behaviour.

You should avoid pressuring your child to explain their feelings or asking them to choose between their parents.

If arrangements cannot be agreed, mediation may be an appropriate option, although it will not be suitable in every case, particularly where there are domestic abuse or safeguarding concerns.

Where necessary, an application can be made to the Family Court for a Child Arrangements Order, or an existing order may be capable of enforcement or variation.

Seeking legal advice at an early stage can help you understand your options and determine the most appropriate way forward.

Putting Children First

Separation can be difficult for everyone involved, but children should never feel responsible for managing their parents' emotions or resolving disagreements between them.

Children should be supported in maintaining safe and positive relationships with both parents wherever this is in their best interests.

It is equally important that children feel listened to and that their genuine worries or concerns are taken seriously.

Ultimately, the focus should not be on winning a dispute between parents, but on ensuring that children feel safe, secure and supported.

How Can Harrington Family Law Help?

At Harrington Family Law, we understand how emotionally challenging disputes involving children can be, particularly where one parent feels that their relationship with their child is being damaged.

Our experienced family law solicitors can assist with concerns about alienating behaviours, disagreements over child arrangements, applications to the Family Court and the enforcement or variation of existing orders.

We provide practical, straightforward advice tailored to your family's circumstances, always keeping the child's welfare at the centre of our approach.

If you are concerned about your child's relationship with you following separation, contact Harrington Family Law today.

We offer a free 30-minute telephone consultation to discuss your circumstances and explain how we may be able to help.

More Articles

More from the Harrington Blog

  • Prenuptial & Postnuptial Agreements | Harrington Family Law

    Considering a prenup or postnup? Discover how prenuptial and postnuptial agreements work in England and Wales and how Harrington Family Law can help.

  • Same-Sex Relationships & Family Law | Harrington Family Law

    Specialist family law advice for same-sex couples and LGBTQ+ families. Harrington Family Law can help with divorce, finances, children and civil partnerships.

  • What if My Ex Refuses Financial Disclosure?

    Is your ex refusing to disclose their finances during divorce? Discover your legal options and how the Court can deal with hidden assets.